The differences between Lync On-Premises and Lync Online (Shared / Dedicated)
May 5th, 2012
| Tags: Lync Server 2010, Office 365
Almost a year ago I wrote a post on the differences between Lync On-Premises and Lync Online, since then Lync Online has gone through a series of updates and I have become more aware of Lync Online for dedicated customers.
Let me cover off some basics for those unaware:
- The Office 365 which can be purchased by individuals, small businesses and medium to large sized Enterprises via the Microsoft Office 365 website – this version of Office 365 is Shared or S and is a shared or multi-tenanted Microsoft Cloud platform aimed at the mass market.
- For large Enterprise businesses (typically 5000+ users), Microsoft offers a dedicated version (or D), which has more similarities between the On-Premises version of Lync Server 2010, the features and deployment characteristics are however not identical. In this dedicated model Microsoft hosts dedicated servers for a specific customer, there is also a more personalised service with enhanced SLA
So back to the matter at hand, I have updated the feature table, the original being sourced from the Office 365-S Lync Online service documentation, with the new features available within the Shared platform and now included the Dedicated version of Lync Online. I hope this helps! 🙂
Features | Lync Server 2010 | Lync Online (S) | Lync Online (D) |
Lync Skill Search in SharePoint Server (on-premises) | Yes | No | Yes |
Lync Skill Search in SharePoint Online | No | No | Yes |
Persistent Group Chat | Yes | No | No |
Privacy mode | Yes | No | No |
Lync external connectivity (federation and Public IM connectivity) | |||
IM/presence/audio/video federation with other OCS/Lync Server/Lync Online organizations | Yes | Yes | Yes |
IM/presence/audio/video with Windows Live Messenger | Yes | Yes | Yes |
IBM Sametime federation | Yes | No | Yes |
IM/presence federation with XMPP networks (Jabber, Google Talk) | Yes | No | Yes – via customer hosted XMPP gateway |
IM/presence with AOL, Yahoo | Yes | No | No |
Meetings (audio/video/web conferencing) | |||
Meeting attendee capacity | 250 | 250 | 250 |
Web Scheduler | Yes (installed separately) | Yes | No |
Desktop sharing | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Application sharing | Yes | Yes | Yes |
White boarding and annotations | Yes | Yes | Yes |
PowerPoint upload for online presentations | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Upload for other file types | No | No | No |
Multimedia content upload | No | No | No |
Polling | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Ad-hoc multiparty PC-based audio/video | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Authenticated attendee in Lync Web App | Yes | No | Yes |
Unauthenticated attendee in Lync Web App | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Lync attendee client | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Scheduled conferences (using Outlook plug-in) | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Outlook delegation for scheduling meetings | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Meeting join via Lync optimized conferencing devices See Meeting Room Devices. Note: Polycom CX7000 is not currently supported | Yes | Partial (RoundTable only) | Yes (Polycom CX7000 is not currently supported) |
Lobby | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Interoperability with certified partners for dial-in audio conferencing (ACP) | No | Yes | No |
Phone dial-out from scheduled meetings via third-party dial-in conferencing service | No | Yes | No |
Client side recording and playback | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Server-side recording and playback | No | No | No |
Generate a link to a scheduled meeting via web page | No | No | No |
Scheduling an online meeting in Outlook Web App | No | No | No |
Exchange Online Outlook Web App and Communicator 2007 R2 or Lync 2010 Integration | No | No | Yes |
Native dial-in audio conferencing on Lync server | Yes | No | Yes |
Screen Snapshot (Desktop Annotation) | No | No | No |
Backstage/Content Preview for presenters | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Mute all attendees | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Mute individual attendees | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Unmute all attendees | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Unmute individual attendees | Yes | Yes | Yes |
In-meeting attendee permission controls | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Interoperability with on-premises video conferencing systems | Yes | No | Yes (via approved customer hosted gateway) |
Voice and telephony | |||
Lync-to-phone (calls with landlines and mobile phones) | Yes | Coming soon via (ACP) | Yes |
Call hold/retrieve | Yes | No | Yes |
Call-via-Work in Lync Mobile | Yes | No | Yes |
Dial-out from ad-hoc Lync meetings | Yes | No | Yes |
Advanced call controls (transfer, forward, simul-ring) | Yes | No | Yes |
Access to Exchange Online voicemail | Yes | No | Yes |
Team call | Yes | No | Yes |
Delegation (boss-admin) for Voice | Yes | No | Yes |
Call park | Yes | No | Yes |
Outgoing DID manipulation | Yes | No | Yes |
E-911 | Yes | No | No |
Dial plans and policies | Yes | No | Yes |
Common Area and IP desk phone support | Yes | No | Yes |
Resilient branch office appliance | Yes | No | No |
Call Admissions Control (CAC) | Yes | No | No |
Support for analog devices (such as FAX) | Yes | No | No |
Response groups | Yes | No | No |
Private Line (secondary DID for executives) | Yes | No | Yes |
Interoperability with third-party PBX or trunks | Yes | No | Yes |
Presence interoperability with third-party PBX | No | No | No |
RCC (click-to-call) with on-premises PBX | Yes | No | No |
Malicious call trace | Yes | No | Yes |
Unassigned number | Yes | No | No |
Network QoS – DSCP | Yes | No | Yes |
Media path optimization | Yes | No | No |
Phone number management | Yes | No | No |
CDR and billing reporting | Yes | No | Yes |
Integration with call center solutions (Aspect) | Yes | No | No |
Client support | |||
Lync 2010 | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Lync Web App for participating in scheduled meetings | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Lync 2010 Attendee client (joining meetings) | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Communicator for Mac client | Yes | No | Yes |
Lync for Mac client | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Office Communicator Web Access (2007 R2) client | Yes | No | No |
Office Communicator 2007 R2 client | Yes | No | No |
Lync 2010 Phone Edition (Lync-based IP phones) | Yes | No | Yes |
Lync 2010 Attendant client (receptionist rich client) | Yes | No | No |
Communicator Mobile (Windows Phones 6.x) | Yes | No | No |
Lync 2010 Mobile client | Yes | Yes | Yes |
BlackBerry Enterprise Server integration for the BlackBerry client with the Lync Server 2010 | Yes | No | Yes |
IM and media encryption | Yes | Yes | Yes |
IM filtering | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Anti-malware scanning for meeting content and file transfers | Yes (partner solutions) | No | No |
IM archiving (server side) | Yes | No | Yes |
Exchange/SharePoint interoperability | |||
Presence interoperability with Exchange and SharePoint on-premises | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Presence interoperability with Exchange Online and SharePoint Online | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Unified Messaging interoperability with Exchange Online | Yes | No | Yes |
Unified Messaging interoperability with Exchange on-premises | Yes | Yes (with Exchange 2010 Hybrid Server) | No |
Lync Online and Lync on-premises, and administration | |||
Lync optimized common area phone and IP phone device auto updates | Yes | No | Yes |
Automatic Lync client update via inband client provisioning | Yes | No | No |
Server/cloud coexistence (split domain) on user basis (some users on-premises, some users online) | No | No | No |
Splitting workloads (for example, IM/presence/voice on-premises, conferencing in the cloud) | No | No | No |
PowerShell support | Yes | No | No |
Bigfin (web) UI | Yes | No | No |
Customer self-service configuration portal | No | Yes | No |
Attendee/user reporting | No | No | No |
Reporting (CDR, QoE) | Yes | No | Yes |
User Management via customer Active Directory | Yes | Yes (with ADFS 2.0) | Yes |
Third-party API support | |||
Client-side APIs | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Server-side APIs | Yes | No | No |
Customer clients using Microsoft SDK | Yes | No | No |
Nice article Adam, thanks for this update to make things more clear!
So, User Management via Customer AD is a no with Lync Online?
Then what is the purpose of AD FS 2.0? Is it not able to authenticate lync clients?
Hi John,
Good shout, I’ve updated the matrix.
– Adam
Good deal Adam, b/c I’m in the middle of that deployment right now. 😉 I’ve still got the proxy servers to install. Currently I’ve got AD FS 2.0 (completely different that AD FS for 2008 R2) working for portal.microsoftonline.com logins…but Lync is still not working. I believe it’s the reverse proxy server that microsoftonline.com needs to complete the lync authentication…. that’s without re-reading the deployment documents.
Can you authenticate your Lync client via the on-premise ADFS 2.0 service? If you can’t then try to login to the control panel via this user and check ADFS pass-thru works without any issue (or cert complaints). Also ensure your registry settings are correct (if you are not using the Office 365 Desktop setup)
– Adam
That’s exactly the issue, I’m not able to authenticate with Lync and our onsite ADFS 2.0 server. However, I can auth with that server using portal.microsoftonline.com! 😉 That’ what’s confusing.
So, registry settings? I don’t recall reading anything about registry settings. I’ve made all the necessary internal DNS changes… what the MS online portal works with the ADFS pass-thru.
I take that back, I’m able to get internal lync working… I’m guessing Friday all of my dNS entries hadn’t taken hold yet. the SRV records.
So, now on to the ADFS 2.0 proxy server and we are fully ready for Lync Online SSO.
Still curious on that registry setting.
Hi John,
See manually configure Lync – here
– Adam